The Value of Less Lethal Weapons in Public Safety
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Less-Lethal Weapons (LLWs) have been a topic of debate in law enforcement, with much of the literature focusing on their legality and convenience rather than their effectiveness, in particular for police agencies. To address this gap, this study employs advanced financial risk analytics and scenario simulation to model the return on investment (ROI) of LLWs usage. By using a type of LLW (The Alternative) as a case study, the results suggest that while extreme events in LLW occur relatively infrequently compared to conventional firearms, their impact on society is significant. For instance, police agencies can have ROI between 1564% and 2728%. For each dollar invested in acquiring, equipping, and training an officer with LLWs, the added benefit is seen between USD$16 and USD$28. Hence, LLWs not only reduce collateral damage, reputational and legal risk, but also prevent unnecessary deaths which erode police legitimacy and public trust.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Urvio, Revista Latinoamericana de Estudios de Seguridad, operates under Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Work 3.0 unported (CC BY-ND 3.0).
The authors who publish in Urvio accept these terms:
You are free to share / copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format for any purpose, including commercial. Therefore, authors retain the copyright and cede to the journal the right of the first publication (CC by-ND 3.0), which allows third parties the redistribution, commercial or noncommercial, of what is published as long as the article circulates without changes.
The following conditions exist for the authors:
Recognition - you must recognize the authorship, provide a link to the license and indicate whether changes have been made. You can do this in any way reasonable, but not in a way that suggest that has the support of the licensor or receives it by the use he makes.
Without Derivative Work – If you remixed, transform or create a work from the original material, you cannot broadcast the modified material.
For more details, visit the page of Creative Commons (CC).
References
ACLU Massachusetts. 2015. “Fuerza Menos Letal: Estándares propuestos para las agencias de la Fuerza del Orden de Massachusetts”, bit.ly/3mrKAZO
ACNUDH (Oficina del Alto Comisionado de las Naciones Unidas para los Derechos Humanos). 2021. “Orientaciones de las Naciones Unidas en Materia de Derechos Humanos sobre el Empleo de Armas Menos Letales en el Mantenimiento del Orden”, bit.ly/3zKoYuJ
Adams, Kenneth, y Victoria Jennison. 2007. “What we do not know about police use of Tasers™”. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management 30(3): 447-465. doi.org/10.1108/13639510710778831
Alexander, John B. 2001. “An overview of the future of non?lethal weapons”. Medicine, Conflict and Survival 17(3): 180-193. doi.org/10.1080/13623690108409578
Alpers, Philip, y Marcus Wilson. 2023. “Global Impact of Gun Violence: Firearms, public health and safety”. GunPolicy.org, 15 de julio. https://bit.ly/3E8FfM0
Alpert, Geoffrey P., Michael R. Smith, Robert J. Kaminski, Lorie A. Fridell, John MacDonald y Bruce Kubu. 2011. “Police use of force, TASERs and other less-lethal weapons”. NIJ Research in Brief 5: 1-19. doi.org//10.13140/RG.2.1.5100.4647
Alternative Ballistics. 2021. “Ballistic Performance Testing of The Alternative”, bit.ly/3mlOtzn
Alternative Ballistics. 2023. “Terms of the Offering”, bit.ly/3MyFpSh
Álvarez-Velasco, Carla-Morena. 2022. “Armas de fuego en América Latina: una sociedad sin conflicto, pero sin paz”. URVIO. Revista Latinoamericana De Estudios De Seguridad 32: 60-75. doi.org/10.17141/urvio.32.2022.4864
Amnistía Internacional. 2021. “Amnesty International Report 2021/22: The state of the world’s human rights”, bit.ly/3ZX0A3p
Aparicio Barrera, Juan. 2003. La ideología de la Policía Nacional de Colombia en las décadas de los 60 y 70. Bogotá: Universidad Nacional de Colombia. Facultad de Derecho.
Archbold, Carol A. 2005. “Managing the bottom line: risk management in policing”. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management 28(1): 30-48. doi.org/10.1108/13639510510580968
Ávila, Marianela, Fernanda Proaño Cortez y Andrés Gómez-Seguel. 2014. “Definiciones y clasificaciones de armas de fuego”. URVIO: Revista Latinoamericana de Estudios de Seguridad 10: 136-157. doi.org/10.17141/urvio.10.2011.1150
Bittner, Egon. 1970. The Functions of the Police in Modern Society: A Review of Background Factors, Current Practices, and Possible Role Models. Crime and Delinquency Issues. Wisconsin: National Institute of Mental Health. goo.su/YfJi
Blalock, Joyce. 1974. Civil Liability of Law Enforcement Officers. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas Publisher.
Borges, J., C. Sautier, L. Krebs-Drouot, P. Henry, F. Paysant y V. Scolan. 2022. “Death and non-lethal weapons: a case of homicide by penetrating injury without projectile”. Forensic Science International 337: 111374. doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2022.111374
Bostic, Michael J. 1994. “New Law Enforcement Challenge: Limiting Use of Force to Solely Nonlethal Weapons”, bit.ly/3L1ZDSV
Bulman, Philip. 2011. “Police use of force: The impact of less-lethal weapons and tactics”. National Institute of Justice, Research in Brief 267: 1-10. https://bit.ly/3YXpstg
Cano, Ignacio, Carlos Silva y Catalina Pérez Correa. 2022. “Monitor of Use of Lethal Force in Latin America and the Caribbean. Comparative Study of Brazil, Chile, Colombia, El Salvador, Jamaica, Mexico, Trinidad and Tobago and Venezuela”, bit.ly/3ZUJAed
Caprirolo, Dino, Rogelio Granguillhome Ochoa, Philip Keefer, Ted Leggett, James Andrew Lewis, José Antonio Mejía-Guerra, Marcela Mello, Heather Sutton y Iván Torre. 2017. The costs of crime and violence: new evidence and insights in Latin America and the Caribbean. Washington: Inter-American Development Bank. bit.ly/3E9hZ0v
Casey-Maslen, Stuart, Christof Heyns y Thomas Probert. 2022. “The use of less-lethal weapons for law enforcement during armed conflict”. En Research Handbook on Human Rights and Humanitarian Law, editado por Robert Kolb y Gloria Gaggioli, 290-308. Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Craig, Ellis. 1977. “Innocent Victims of a Police Action”. University of New Brunswick Law Journal 26: 34-47.
Cox, Tommy. 2005. “Less lethal weapons”, bit.ly/43mK3c4
Demir, Erdem Eren, Mehmet Ali Tekiner y Aybuke A. Isbir Turan. 2022. “The Role of Non-Lethal Weapons in Public Security”. J. Crimin. & Crim. L. 60: 59-75. doi org/10. 47152/rkkp. 60.3.4
Dobrowolski, Alan, y Sue Moore. 2005. “Less lethal weapons and their impact on patient care”. Advanced Emergency Nursing Journal 27(1): 44-49.
FBI (Buró Federal de Investigaciones). 2021. “Statistics for Law Enforcement Officers Assaulted and Killed in the Line of Duty”, bit.ly/3mwpHwl
Geis, Gilbert, y Arnold Binder. 1990. “Non-lethal weapons: The potential and the pitfalls”. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 6(1): 1-7.
Geneva Declaration Secretariat. 2008. “Geneva Declaration on Armed Violence and Development: Global Burden of Armed Violence”, bit.ly/3P905kM
Gun Violence Archive. 2023. “Data and Statistics of the Gun Violence Archive”, bit.ly/2q7sf3c
Haar, Rohini J., Vincent Iacopino, Nikhil Ranadive, Sheri D. Weiser y Madhavi Dandu. 2017. “Health impacts of chemical irritants used for crowd control: a systematic review of the injuries and deaths caused by tear gas and pepper spray”. BMC public health 17(1): 1-14.
Heresmann, Ian Badiola. 2011. “Función policial, democracia y accountability”. Revista Logos, Ciencia & Tecnología 2(2): 188-201.
Hickman, Matthew J., Jared N. Strote, Robert M. Scales, William S. Parkin y Peter A. Collins. 2021. “Police use of force and injury: Multilevel predictors of physical harm to subjects and officers”. Police Quarterly 24(3): 267-297.
Hirschfield, Paul J. 2023. “Exceptionally lethal: American police killings in a comparative perspective”. Annual Review of Criminology 6:471-498. doi.org/10.1146/annurev-criminol-030421-040247
Hougland, Steve, Charlie Mesloh y Mark Henych. 2005. “Use of force, civil litigation, and the taser: one agency's experience”. FBI L. Enforcement Bulletin 74: 24-30. https://goo.su/sA2Nf
Instituto Thurgood Marshall. 2022. “The National Police Funding Database, Thurgood Marshall Institute”. 16 de junio de 2022. goo.su/j4VWz
Kjellman, Timothy Robert. 2016. “Less Lethal Weapons: An Effectiveness Analysis”, bit.ly/3GxpakC
Kunz, Sebastian N., Hugh Calkins, Jiri Adamec y Mark W. Kroll. 2018. “Cardiac and skeletal muscle effects of electrical weapons: a review of human and animal studies”. Forensic Science, Medicine and Pathology 14: 358-366. doi.org/10.1007/s12024-018-9997-3
Lewer, Nick, y Neil Davison. 2005. “Non-lethal technologies—an overview”. Disarmament forum 1:37-51. https://bit.ly/45KgRMw
Mapping Police Violence. 2023. “Mapping Police Violence”, bit.ly/3nWR1UR
MDNPNC (Ministerio de Defensa Nacional Policía Nacional de Colombia). 2017. “Resolución 02903”, bit.ly/3KP1CKt
Mesloh, Charlie, Mark Henych y Ross Wolf. 2008. “Less lethal weapon effectiveness, use of force, and suspect & officer injuries: A five-year analysis”, bit.ly/41fafUa
Mun, Johnathan. 2010. Modeling risk: Applying Monte Carlo risk simulation, strategic real options, stochastic forecasting, and portfolio optimization. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons.
Naghavi, Mohsen, Laurie B. Marczak, Michael Kutz, Katya Anne Shackelford, Megha Arora, Molly Miller-Petrie y Miloud Taki Eddine Aichour. 2018. “Global mortality from firearms, 1990-2016”. Jama 320(8): 792-814. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.10060
Naval Studies Board y National Research Council. 2003. An assessment of non-lethal weapons science and technology. Washington: National Academies Press.
Oramas Mora, Daniela, William Terrill y Jacob Foster. 2023. “A Decade of Police Use of Deadly Force Research (2011–2020)”. Homicide Studies 27(1): 6-33. doi.org/10.1177/1088767922112
Otamendi, María Alejandra. 2019. “Juvenicidio armado: homicidios de jóvenes y armas de fuego en América Latina”. Salud Colectiva 15: 1-6. doi.org/10.18294/sc.2019.1690
PERF (Police Executive Research Forum). 2016. “Guiding Principles on Use of Force. Critical Issues in Policing Series”, bit.ly/2VqnkIz
Reid, Tim, Peter Eisler y Grant Smith. 2019. “As death toll keeps rising, US communities start rethinking Taser use”. Reuters, 4 de febrero. https://reut.rs/45pCBxw
Reina Arias, Edna Rocío. 2018. “Armas no letales en seguridad privada en Colombia”, bit.ly/3KUrft7
Serna-Mora, María Teresa. 2021. “Armas menos letales en intervenciones policiales para el fortalecimiento de la seguridad ciudadana en el Perú”, bit.ly/45N9tjv
Sheppard, Keller G., y Brandon C. Welsh. 2022. “Can police use of less-than-lethal weapons reduce harm during violent police-citizen encounters? A systematic review and directions for future research”. Aggression and violent behavior 64:101748. doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2022.101748
Statista. 2020. “The number of nonfederal police officers arrested for murder who have been convicted between 2005 and 2020 by charge”, bit.ly/3KPkEk3
Strote, Jared, Mimi Walsh, Matthew Angelidis, Amaya Basta y H. Range Hutson. 2010. “Conducted electrical weapon use by law enforcement: an evaluation of safety and injury”. Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery 68 (5): 1239-1246. doi.org/10.1097/TA.0b013e3181b28b78
UNLIREC (United Nations Regional Centre for Peace, Disarmament and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean). 2016. “Armas menos letales en América Latina y el Caribe. Retos y oportunidades”, https://bit.ly/3KQkJ74
White, Michael D., y Justin Ready. 2007. “The TASER as a less lethal force alternative: Findings on use and effectiveness in a large metropolitan police agency”. Police quarterly 10(2): 170-191. doi.org/10.1177/1098611106288915