China's Economic Presence in South America: Implications for the Dynamics of Intraregional Cooperation

Main Article Content

Juliana Gonzalez Jauregui, Dra.
Diana Tussie, Dra.

Abstract

This article analyzes the Chinese economic presence in South America within the framework of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and beyond it, and the implications for the dynamics of intraregional cooperation, in a context of strategic dispute between China and United States. From a theoretical-methodological approach of International Political Economy, we seek to understand the processes of structural change and the consequent constraints and/or possibilities for social actors. We identify the most relevant actors and the interactions between the domestic, subregional and global levels of analysis. We carry out a specific case study, in particular, we analyze how the presence of multiple Chinese actors in the subregion evolved through digital, energy, and logistics and transportation projects, before and after the invitation to Latin America to be part of the BRI. We explain how the Chinese presence materializes through the "creation of geography". The analysis includes the reactions of the United States and the implications of these responses for intra-regional dynamics in South America. In the conclusions, we offer reflections on how the Chinese presence modifies interests and preferences, and influences the domestic and global levels, and how it contributes to reconfigure the dynamics of South American cooperation.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Gonzalez-Jauregui, J., & Tussie, D. (2023). China’s Economic Presence in South America: Implications for the Dynamics of Intraregional Cooperation. URVIO. Revista Latinoamericana De Estudios De Seguridad, (36), 8–25. https://doi.org/10.17141/urvio.36.2023.5936
Section
Tema central
Author Biographies

Juliana Gonzalez Jauregui, Dra., FLACSO/CONICET

Juliana González Jáuregui has a degree in International Relations, a Master's in International Relations and Negotiations from FLACSO Argentina and the San Andrés University, and a PhD in Social Sciences from FLACSO Argentina. Currently, she works as an Assistant Researcher at CONICET, within the framework of the Program for the Strengthening of Research and Cooperation with China / Asia in the field of R + D + i. She coordinates the Chair of Studies on China and the Higher Diploma in Studies on Latin America and China in the International Relations Area of FLACSO Argentina, where she is also a professor in the Master's Degree in International Relations. She also participates in various instances of postgraduate training at the national and regional level. She completed a doctoral research stay within the framework of the European program GRE: EN GEM in conjunction with Fudan University (2012). She carried out postgraduate research stays at the PUC of Chile (2014) and Brown University (2018). In 2021, she was selected and awarded a scholarship to carry out a postdoctoral research stay at ILAS-Columbia University.

Among her most recent contributions are listed:

“China’s presence in Argentina’s lithium sector”. Wilson Center (en prensa).

“Latin America and China's Belt and Road Initiative: Challenges and Proposals from a Latin American Perspective", con Ramiro Fernández y Gabriel Merino. Austral. Brazilian Journal of Strategy & International Relations (en prensa).

“Alianzas estratégicas con China en el sector del litio: implicaciones para el desarrollo e inserción internacional de Argentina”. En América Latina y China: nuevos rumbos de la vieja dependencia, editado por Rubén Laufer y Fernando Romero Wimer. Buenos Aires: CEISO (en prensa).

“Latin America-Caribbean-China Knowledge Networks: State of the Field”, con Alejandra Gutierrez, Francisca Aguayo Armijo, y Yanqiu Zheng. Social Science Research Council. Diciembre 2022.

“Financiamiento e inversiones de China en energías renovables en Argentina: implicaciones para la transición energética y el desarrollo”. Revista Ciencias Sociales (segunda época) 13 (42): 177-198. Septiembre 2022.

“China’s BRI Extension to South America: Challenges and Opportunities for the Regional Order in the Post-pandemic”, con Diana Tussie. En Regional and International Cooperation in South America: Challenges and Opportunities for the Post-Pandemic, editado por Melisa Deciancio y Cintia Quiliconi. Londres: Routledge Publishers, 2022.

“Chinese Overseas Finance in Renewable Energy in Argentina and Brazil: Implications for the Energy Transition”, con Tatiana Gélvez.  Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, Special Issue. Marzo 2022.

“Latin American Countries in the BRI: Challenges and Potential Implications for Economic Development”. Asian Education and Development Studies, Special Issue, Marzo 2020.

Diana Tussie, Dra., Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences

Diana Tussie has a degree in Sociology and a PhD in International Relations from the London School of Economics. Currently, she is a Senior Researcher at the National Council for Scientific and Technical Research (CONICET) of Argentina. She directs the Master's Degree in International Relations at FLACSO / Argentina. She has vast experience in public policy, and has specialized in amalgamating the field of International Relations with the field of international political economy. She was a member of the UN Committee for Development Policies and a consultant to various international organizations, a visiting researcher at universities in Uruguay, Ecuador, Chile, the United Kingdom and Germany.

Among her most recent contributions are listed:

“The Politics of International Development”, editado con Melisa Deciancio y Pablo Nemiña. Londres: Elgar. 2022.

“¿Crisis de la cooperación regional o crisis de la cooperación?: Repensar la cooperación regional para la era pospandémica”, con Melisa Deciancio. En América Latina: ¿Hay voluntad política para construir un futuro diferente?, editado por Josette Altmann Borbón y Francisco Rojas Aravena. San José de Costa Rica: FLACSO.

“China’s BRI Extension to South America: Challenges and Opportunities for the Regional Order in the Post-pandemic”, con Juliana González Jáuregui. En Regional and International Cooperation in South America: Challenges and Opportunities for the Post-Pandemic, editado por Melisa Deciancio y Cintia Quiliconi. Londres: Routledge Publishers, 2022.

“Misrecognised, misfit and misperceived: why not a Latin American school of IPE?”, con Fabricio Chagas-Bastos. Review of International Political Economy. Mayo 2022.

“How Does Gramsci Travel in Latin America? Before and After Critical International Relations Theory”, con Leonardo Ramos. Contexto Internacional 44 (1). Enero/Abril2022.

“Latin America in Global International Relations”, editado con Melisa Deciancio y Amitav Acharya. Milton Park: Routledge. 2021.

“Post hegemonic policies in South America: the case of financial cooperation”, con Pablo Nemiña. Sur Global 2 (2). 2021.

References

Acharya, Amitav. 2009. “Regional Worlds in a Post?hegemonic Era”. Cahiers de Spirit/Spirit Working Papers 1: 1-13. https://bit.ly/445EO0J

Actis, Esteban, y Nicolás Creus. 2020. La disputa por el poder global: China contra Estados Unidos en la crisis de la pandemia. Buenos Aires: Capital Intelectual.

Albright, Zarah, Rebecca Ray y Yudong Liu. 2022. “China-Latin America and

the Caribbean”, bit.ly/3AxZqBd

Battaleme, Juan. 2022. “¿Atrapados sin salida? El compromiso selectivo como alternativa de política exterior para un país periférico”. Revista Política Austral 1(1): 33-52. doi.org/10.26422/RPA.2022.0101.bat

Bernal-Meza, Raúl. 2016. “China and Latin America Relations: The Win-Win Rhetoric”, bit.ly/41TVm9U

Bogado Bordazar, Laura, y Juan Margueliche. 2022. “Infraestructura latinoamericana e inversión china. Una cadena de cooperación mutua en la nueva alternativa de globalización”. En China y el Nuevo Mapa del Poder Mundial, editado por Gabriel Merino, Lourdes Regueiro Bello y Wagner Iglecias, 193-219. Buenos Aires: CLACSO.

Boston University Global Development Policy Center. 2023. China’s Global Energy Finance Database. Boston: Boston University.

Creutzfeldt, Benjamin. 2016. “One Actor, Many Agents: China’s Latin America Policy in Theory and Practice”. En The Political Economy of China-Latin America Relations in the New Millennium: Brave New World, editado por Margaret Myers y Carol Wise, 28-47. Nueva York: Routledge.

Crivelli Minutti, Eduardo, y Giuseppe Lo Brutto. 2018. “La cooperación de China en América Latina: ‘Hacia una nueva Economía Estructural?”. Revista Carta Internacional 13(2): 123-146. doi.org/10.21530/ci.v13n2.2018.806

Eder, Thomas, Rebecca Arcesati y Jacob Mardell. 2019. Networking the “Belt and Road”. Merics, 27 de febrero. https://bit.ly/3n9UkIp

Fornés, Gastón, y Álvaro Méndez. 2018. The China-Latin America Axis: Emerging Markets and their Role in an Increasingly Globalized World. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

Fortín, Carlos, Jorge Heine y Carlos Ominami. 2021. “Introducción”. En El no alineamientoactivo y América Latina: Una doctrina para el nuevo siglo, editado por Carlos Fortín, Jorge Heine y Carlos Ominami, 17-36. Santiago de Chile: Catalonia Libros.

Gelvez, Tatiana, y Juliana Gonzalez Jauregui. 2022. “Chinese Overseas Finance in Renewables in Argentina and Brazil: Implications for Energy Transition”. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 51(1): 137-164. doi.org/10.1177/18681026221094852

Gonzalez Jauregui, Juliana. 2021a. “How Argentina Pushed Chinese Investors to Help Revitalize Its Energy Grid”. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 20 de febrero. https://bit.ly/3NfTh4b

Gonzalez Jauregui, Juliana. 2021b. “China en América Latina: la estrategia regional pendiente”. En El Estado de las Negociaciones Comerciales Internacionales: Dossier especial: A 30 años del Tratado de Asunción: presente y futuro del Mercosur, editado por Magdalena Bas Vilizzio y Julieta Zelicovich, 36-38. Rosario: UNR/GENCI. bit.ly/3HlBapI

Gonzalez Jauregui, Juliana, y Diana Tussie. 2022. “China’s BRI Extension to South America: Challenges and Opportunities for the Regional Order in the Post-pandemic”. En Regional and International Cooperation in South America after COVID: Challenges and Opportunities Post-Pandemic, editado por Melisa Deciancio y Cintia Quiliconi, 43-62. Nueva York: Routledge.

Hook, Leslie, y Henry Sanderson. 2021. “How the race for renewable energy is reshaping global politics”. Financial Times, 4 de febrero. https://bit.ly/3NjH3aR

Jenkins, Rhys. 2022. “China’s Belt and Road Initiative in Latin America: What has Changed?”. Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 51(1): 13-39. doi.org/10.1177/18681026211047871

Krugman, Paul. 1992. Geography and Trade. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Laufer, Rubén. 2020. “El proyecto chino “La Franja y la Ruta” y América Latina: ¿otro Norte para el Sur?”. Revista Interdisciplinaria de Estudios Sociales 20(7): 9-52. https://bit.ly/41HkKAr

Legler, Thomas, Mariano Turzi y Eduardo Tzili-Apango. 2018. “China y la Búsqueda de la Gobernanza Regional Autónoma en América Latina”. Revista CIDOB d’Afers Internacionals 119: 245-264. https://bit.ly/3W19oFp

Legler, Thomas, Mariano Turzi y Eduardo Tzili-Apango. 2020. “Advancing Autonomy? Chinese Influence on Regional Governance in Latin America”. En China and Latin American Relations in the XXI Century: The Dual Complexities of Opportunities and Challenges, editado por Raúl Bernal-Meza y Li Xing, 27-48. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

Morgenfeld, Leandro. 2018. “Nuestra América frente a la reactualización de la Doctrina Monroe”. En Estados Unidos contra el mundo. Trump y la nueva geopolítica, editado por Casandra Castorena Sánchez, Marco Gandásegui Jr. y Leandro Morgenfeld, 217-236. Buenos Aires: CLACSO.

Myers, Margaret, y Ricardo Barrios. 2021. “How China Ranks Its Partners in LAC”. The Dialogue, 3 de febrero. https://bit.ly/3LhpTbc

Myers, Margaret, y Rebecca Ray. 2023. “At a Crossroads: Chinese Development Finance to Latin America and The Caribbean, 2022”, bit.ly/3Vc0i85

Nolte, Detleff, y Brigitte Weiffen. 2021. “Introduction: Regionalism Under Stress”. En Regionalism Under Stress: Europe and Latin America in Comparative Perspective, editado por Detleff Nolte y Brigitte Weiffen, 1-12. Londres: Routledge.

Paikin, Damián, y Federico Dulcich. 2017. “El sexto socio del MERCOSUR: un estudio sobre la penetración importadora china y su impacto en el comercio intrarregional”. Revista Perspectivas de Políticas Públicas 6(12): 395-414. doi.org/10.18294/rppp.2017.1514

Parra Pérez, Águeda. 2020. “La ruta de la seda digital: la gran globalización china”, bit.ly/3NmG2Ph

Quiliconi, Cintia. 2013. “Modelos competitivos de integración en el hemisferio occidental: ¿liderazgo competitivo o negación mutua?”. Revista CIDOB d’Afers Internacionals 102-103: 147-168. https://bit.ly/44cAFsa

Ramón-Berjano, Carola. 2019. “Globalización con ‘Características Chinas’. El Creciente Rol de China en América Latina y el Caribe y sus Principales Desafíos”. Pensamiento Propio 24(49-50): 31-52. https://bit.ly/3LYevRR

Rapoport, Mario, y María Cecilia Miguez. 2015. “Desafíos y ejes para una inserción internacional autónoma de Argentina y América del Sur en el escenario mundial”. En Integración y cooperación regional en América Latina. Una relectura a partir de la teoría de la autonomía, editado por José Briceño Ruiz y Alejandro Simonoff, 143-162. Buenos Aires: Biblos.

Riggirozzi, Pia, y Diana Tussie. 2012. The Rise of Post-Hegemonic Regionalism. Londres: Springer.

Sanahuja, José. 2012. “Post-liberal regionalism in South America: The case of UNASUR”, bit.ly/43bm52C

Tokatlián, Juan. 2021. “Estados Unidos y América Latina: por una diplomacia de equidistancia”. En El no alineamiento activo y América Latina: Una doctrina para un nuevo siglo, editado por Carlos Fortín, Jorge Heine y Carlos Ominami, 61-82. Santiago de Chile: Catalonia Libros.

Tussie, Diana. 2019. “La reconfiguración global: su capítulo en vivo para América Latina”. En América Latina frente a la reconfiguración global, editado por Josette Altmann Borbón, 107-119. San José: FLACSO.

Vadell, Javier. 2022. “China y el Poder Blando Relacional: El Caso del Fórum China-CELAC”. En China y el Nuevo Mapa del Poder Mundial, editado por Gabriel Merino, Lourdes Regueiro Bello y Wagner Iglecias, 167-191. Buenos Aires: CLACSO.

Yin, Robert. 1994. Investigación sobre estudio de casos. Diseño y métodos. Londres: SAGE Publications.