Nature on Canvas: Narrations on Human-Nature Relationships through Art-Based Methods in La Paz, Bolivia
Main Article Content
Abstract
Arts-based research offers innovative ways to study human-nature relationships. We conducted an exploratory study with inhabitants of the city of La Paz in Bolivia, using drawings as an art-based approach to understand how people value and relate to municipal protected areas. Thirty-seven people participated in a drawing competition organized by one of the municipal protected areas where participants depicted some element (landscape, species) of the protected areas that they considered inspiring and reflective of the importance of these areas. Participants highlighted different protected areas; most drew specific local plants or animals, and they expressed various forms of intrinsic, instrumental and relational values. Our pilot study demonstrates how an arts-based approach has potential as a research tool, revealing underexplored aspects of human-nature relationships. We conclude that arts-based approaches can highlight plural values and local ecological knowledge, which provides opportunities to rethink participatory management and environmental education, and inform policy toward sustainability.
Downloads
Article Details
Letras Verdes, Revista Latinoamericana de Estudios Socioambientales, operates under Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Work 3.0 unported (CC BY-ND 3.0).
The authors who publish in Letras Verdes accept these terms:
You are free to share / copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format for any purpose, including commercial. Therefore, authors retain the copyright and cede to the journal the right of the first publication (CC by-ND 3.0), which allows third parties the redistribution, commercial or noncommercial, of what is published as long as the article circulates without changes.
The following conditions exist for the authors:
Recognition - you must recognize the authorship, provide a link to the license and indicate whether changes have been made. You can do this in any way reasonable, but not in a way that suggest that has the support of the licensor or receives it by the use he makes.
Without Derivative Work – If you remixed, transform or create a work from the original material, you cannot broadcast the modified material.
For more details, visit the page of Creative Commons (CC).
References
Ballouard, Jean Marie, François Brischoux y Xavier Bonnet. 2011. “Children Prioritize Virtual Exotic Biodiversity over Local Biodiversity”. PLoS ONE 6 (8). https://bit.ly/3cuMLpV
Bardsley, Douglas K., Elisa Palazzo y Randy Stringer. 2019. “What should we conserve? Farmer narratives on biodiversity values in the McLaren Vale, South Australia”. Land Use Policy 83: 594-605. https://bit.ly/3JzEWM2
Barraza, Laura. 1999. “Children’s drawings about the environment”. Environmental Education Research 5 (1): 49-66. https://bit.ly/3cWPUiz
Bentz, Julia, Letícia do Carmo, Nicole Schafenacker, Jörn Schirok y Sara D. Corso. 2022. “Creative, Embodied Practices, and the Potentialities for Sustainability Transformations”. Sustainability Science 17 (2): 687–699. https://bit.ly/3w88yuP
Blanc, Nathalie. 2000. Les animaux et la ville. París: Odile Jacob.
Bowker, Rob. 2007. “Children’s Perceptions and Learning about Tropical Rainforests: An Analysis of Their Drawings”. Environmental Education Research 13 (1): 75–96. https://bit.ly/3S2bWQT
Celis-Diez, Juan L., Javiera Díaz-Forestier, Marcela Márquez-García, Silvia Lazzarino, Ricardo Rozzi y Juan J. Armesto. 2016. “Biodiversity Knowledge Loss in Children’s Books and Textbooks”. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 14 (8): 408–10. https://bit.ly/3ba6A5O
Chan, Kai M.A., Patricia Balvanera, Karina Benessaiah, Mollie Chapman, Sandra Díaz, Erik Gómez-Baggethun, Rachelle Gould, Neil Hannahs, Kurt Jax, Sarah Klain, Gary W. Luck, Berta Martín-López, Barbara Muraca, Bryan Norton, Konrad Ott, Unai Pascual, Terre Satterfield, Marc Tadaki, Jonathan Taggart y Nancy Turner. 2016. “Why Protect Nature? Rethinking Values and the Environment”. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 113 (6): 1462-1465. https://bit.ly/3PBmKEd
Edwards, David M., Timothy M. Collins y Reiko Goto. 2016. “An Arts-Led Dialogue to Elicit Shared, Plural and Cultural Values of Ecosystems”. Ecosystem Services 21: 319-328. https://bit.ly/3Q7pGJ1
Elo, Satu, y Helvi Kyngäs. 2008. “The Qualitative Content Analysis Process”. Journal of Advanced Nursing 62 (1): 107-115. https://bit.ly/3Bhrla5
Galafassi, Diego, Sacha Kagan, Manjana Milkoreit, María Heras, Chantal Bilodeau, Sadhbh Juarez Bourke, Andrew Merrie, Leonie Guerrero, Guðrún Pétursdóttir y Joan David Tàbara. 2018. “Raising the temperature: the arts in a warming planet”. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 31: 71-79. https://bit.ly/3bwTY96
Garitano-Zavala, Álvaro, Jackeline Campos, Patricia Ascarrunz y Zulma Chura. 2009. “La ornitofauna de las áreas protegidas municipales y de otras áreas periurbanas del valle de La Paz: la importancia de los corredores ecológicos en la matriz urbana”. Ponencia presentada en la Conferencia Biodiversidad y Ecología en Bolivia, Universidad Mayor de San Andrés, La Paz, Bolivia, enero.
Genovart, Meritxell, Giacomo Tavecchia, Juan José Enseñat y Paola Laiolo. 2013. “Holding up a Mirror to the Society: Children Recognize Exotic Species Much More than Local Ones”. Biological Conservation 159: 484-489. https://bit.ly/3RZ3EcB
Gobierno Autónomo Municipal de La Paz. 2017. “Aspectos Político Institucionales: región metropolitana del departamento de La Paz”, https://bit.ly/3z5jXfy
Heinrichs, Harald. 2018. “Sustainability Science with Ozzy Osbourne, Julia Roberts, and Ai Weiwei”. Gaia 27 (1): 132-137. https://bit.ly/3S49k52
Hensler, Loni, Juliana Merçon y Ulli Vilsmaier. 2021. “Diverse Values and a Common Utopia: Insights from a Participatory Art-Based Plural Valuation Experience in Xalapa, Mexico”. Case Studies in the Environment 5 (1). https://bit.ly/3vgOVQv
Heras, María, Diego Galafassi, Elisa Oteros-Rozas, Federica Ravera, Luis Berraquero-Díaz y Isabel Ruiz-Mallén. 2021. “Realising Potentials for Arts-Based Sustainability Science”. Sustainability Science 16 (6): 1875-1889. https://bit.ly/3BLGOQ5
Hermida Rosales, Carlos Hugo. 2020. “Áreas verdes urbanas, de gran valor para reducir estrés y ansiedad”. Universo, 10 de agosto. https://bit.ly/3zuRHEr
Himes, Austin, y Barbara Muraca. 2018. “Relational values: the key to pluralistic valuation of ecosystem services”. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 35: 1-7. https://bit.ly/3z9Wdql
Holm, Gunilla, Fritjof Sahlström y Harriet Zilliacus. 2018. “Arts ‑ Based Visual Research”. En Handbook of Arts-Based Research, editado por Patricia Leavy, 311–35. Nueva York: Guilford Press.
Instituto Nacional de Estadística. 2015. “Censo de población y vivienda 2012: características de la población”, https://bit.ly/3PXAZD9
IPBES. 2022. Methodological assessment of the diverse values and valuation of nature of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. Bonn: IPBES Secretariat. https://bit.ly/3Jychaq
IPBES. 2019. Global assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. Bonn: IPBES secretariat. https://bit.ly/3zHywrf
Ives, Christopher D., David J. Abson, Henrik von Wehrden, Christian Dorninger, Kathleen Klaniecki y Joern Fischer. 2018. “Reconnecting with Nature for Sustainability”. Sustainability Science 13 (5): 1389-1397. https://bit.ly/3zyks32
Koch, Larissa, Philipp Gorris, y Claudia Pahl-Wostl. 2021. “Narratives, Narrations and Social Structure in Environmental Governance”. Global Environmental Change 69. https://bit.ly/3zaWysW
Krtolica, Igor. 2021. Gilles Deleuze. París: Presses Universitaires de France/Humensis.
Levin, Kasper. 2013. “Becoming worthy of what happens to us: Art and subjectivity in the philosophy of Gilles Deleuze”. En Art and identity: Essays on the aesthetic creation of mind, editado por Roald Tone y Johannes Lang, 135-167. Amsterdam/ New York: Editions Rodopi. https://bit.ly/3Sxd4wv
Ma, Anson T.H., Theresa W.L. Lam, Lewis T.O. Cheung, y Lincoln Fok. 2021. “Protected Areas as a Space for Pandemic Disease Adaptation: A Case of COVID-19 in Hong Kong”. Landscape and Urban Planning 207. https://bit.ly/3b3sass
Maas, Bea, Yvonne Fabian, Sara M. Kross y Anett Richter. 2021. “Divergent Farmer and Scientist Perceptions of Agricultural Biodiversity, Ecosystem Services and Decision-Making”. Biological Conservation 256. https://bit.ly/3vwH15Q
McKinney, Michael L. 2008. “Effects of Urbanization on Species Richness: A Review of Plants and Animals”. Urban Ecosystems 11 (2): 161-176. https://bit.ly/3oya9pr
Mejía, María Angélica. 2016. Naturaleza urbana. Plataforma de experiencias. Bogotá: Instituto Alexander von Humboldt.
Moya, M. Isabel, Meneses Rosa Isela, y Jaime Sarmiento. 2017. Historia natural del valle de La Paz. La Paz: Museo Nacional de Historia Natural/Instituto de Ecología.
Muhr, Maximilian M. 2020. “Beyond Words–the Potential of Arts-Based Research on Human-Nature Connectedness”. Ecosystems and People 16 (1): 249-257. https://bit.ly/3BfjCtl
Nisbet, Elizabeth K., John M. Zelenski y Steven A. Murphy. 2008. “With Nature to Environmental Concern and Behavior”. Environment And Behavior 27 (1): 1-26. https://bit.ly/3b3SV06.
Osorio, Francisco, Chura Zulma y Mariana Da Silva. 2017. “Las áreas protegidas en el valle de La Paz”. En Historia natural del valle de La Paz, editado por Isabel Moya, Rosa-Isela Meneses y Jaime Sarmiento, 394-398. La Paz: Museo Nacional de Historia Natural/ Instituto de Ecología.
Pascual, Unai, Patricia Balvanera, Sandra Díaz, György Pataki, Eva Roth, Marie Stenseke y Robert T. Watson. 2017. “Valuing Nature’s Contributions to People: The IPBES Approach”. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 26–27: 7-16. https://bit.ly/3cGO1GP
Poortinga, Wouter, Natasha Bird, Britt Hallingberg, Rhiannon Phillips y Denitza Williams. 2021. “The Role of Perceived Public and Private Green Space in Subjective Health and Wellbeing during and after the First Peak of the COVID-19 Outbreak”. Landscape and Urban Planning 211. https://bit.ly/3oNZya9
Pramova, Emilia, Bruno Locatelli, Merelyn Valdivia-Díaz, Améline Vallet, Yésica Quispe Conde, Houria Djoudi, Matthew J. Colloff, François Bousquet, Jacques Tassin y Claudia Munera Roldan. 2021. “Sensing, Feeling, Thinking: Relating to Nature with the Body, Heart and Mind”. People and Nature 00: 1-14. https://bit.ly/3zuGZxI
Pröpper, Michael H. 2017. “Sustainability Science as If the World Mattered: Sketching an Art Contribution by Comparison”. Ecology and Society 22 (3). https://bit.ly/3PB9Gi6
Raatikainen, Kaisa J., Katja Juhola, Maria Huhmarniemi y Hugo Peña-Lagos. 2020. “‘Face the Cow’: Reconnecting to Nature and Increasing Capacities for pro-Environmental Agency”. Ecosystems and People 16 (1): 273-289. https://bit.ly/3vikvgR
Rodríguez-Labajos, Beatriz. 2022. “Artistic activism promotes three major forms of sustainability transformations”. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability (57). https://bit.ly/3vJS23Y
Sánchez Ávila, Héctor. 2019. “Agricultura urbana y periurbana: Reconfiguraciones territoriales y potencialidades en torno a los sistemas alimentarios urbanos”. Investigaciones Geograficas 98: 1-21. https://bit.ly/3BinhGF
Saratsi, Eirini, Acott Tim, Allinson Ewan, Edwards David, Fremantle Chris y Robert Fish. 2019. Valuing Arts & Arts Research. Londres: Valuing Nature Program. https://bit.ly/3OBtQr1
Tarducci Rodríguez, Rocío, Mariana Birche y Daniela Cortizo. 2021. “Analysis of Public Space in the Face of the Pandemic in an Informal Settlement in Argentina”. Revista de Urbanismo 44: 96-111. https://bit.ly/3zsdWd5
The World Bank. 2022. “Urban population ( % of total population) – Bolivia”, https://bit.ly/3cIAmyT
Turnhout, Esther, y Andy Purvis. 2020. “Biodiversity and Species Extinction: Categorisation, Calculation, and Communication”. Griffith Law Review 29 (4): 669-685. https://bit.ly/3zzroNa
Urías Borbón, Diana Susana, y José Manuel Ochoa de la Torre. 2020. “Huertos Urbanos Como Estrategia de Resiliencia Urbana En Países En Desarrollo”. Vivienda y Comunidades Sustentables 8: 81-102. https://bit.ly/3owBSa4
Wyborn, Carina, y Megan C. Evans. 2021. “Conservation Needs to Break Free from Global Priority Mapping”. Nature Ecology and Evolution 5 (10): 1322-1324. https://bit.ly/3z6HgW3
Zurba, Melanie, y Fikret Berkes. 2014. “ Caring for country through participatory art: creating a boundary object for communicating Indigenous knowledge and values”. Local Environment 19 (8): 821-836. https://bit.ly/3JDB3pL